Sign in

Sign in to OpenClassics for free to save your progress automatically and return to your last passage.

Continue your story?

You have a saved reading position for this text.

Family storiesFairies and magicLove stories

About 15 min to read

One-Eye, Two-Eyes and Three-Eyes

In this German story collected by the Brothers Grimm, a girl is rejected for having two eyes when her sisters have one and three. A meeting while she is tending the goat brings her magical help.

Content warning: A child is rejected, mistreated and deprived of food by her family. A goat is killed.

Piano Trio No. 1 in D minor, Op. 49

Felix Mendelssohn

Emily Bruskin (violin)

Julia Bruskin (cello)

Donna Kwong (piano)

Isabella Stewart Gardner Museum (source)

CC BY-NC-ND 3.0

Text version

Once upon a time there wasThere was once a woman who had three daughters. The eldest, the eldest of whom was called One-EyeOne-eye, because she had only one eye in the middle of her forehead. The second was Two-Eyes, and the second, Two-eyes, because she had two eyes like other people. The youngest was Three-Eyesfolks, and the youngest, Three-eyes, because she had three eyes, with the third; and her third eye was also in the centre of her forehead. However, as Two-EyesTwo-eyes saw just as other human beings did, her sisters and her mother could not standendure her. They said to her, “YouThou, with yourthy two eyes, areart no better than the common people; you dothou dost not belong to us!” They pushed her about, and threw old clothes to her, and gave her nothing to eat but what they left, and did everything that they could to make her unhappy. One day Two-EyesIt came to pass that Two-eyes had to go out into the fields and look aftertend the goat, but she was still quite hungry, because her sisters had given her so little to eat. So she sat down on a ridge and began to weep, and so bitterly that two streams ran down from her eyes. And once when she looked up in her grief, a woman was standing beside her, who said, “Why are you cryingart thou weeping, little Two-EyesTwo-eyes?” Two-Eyes answered, “Don’tHave I havenot reason to cryweep, when I have two eyes like other people, and my sisters and mother hate me for it, and push me from one corner to another, throw old clothes at me, and give me nothing to eat but the scraps they leave? TodayTo-day they have given me so little that I am still quite hungry.” Then the wise woman said, “Wipe away yourthy tears, Two-EyesTwo-eyes, and I will tell youthee something to stop youthee ever suffering from hunger again; just say to yourthy goat,

“Bleat, my little goat, bleat, Cover the table with something to eat,”

and then a  clean well-spread little table neatly laid for a mealtable will stand before youthee, with the most delicious food on it, and you mayupon it of which thou mayst eat as much as you likethou art inclined for, and when you havethou hast had enough, and havehast no more need of the little table, just say,

“Bleat, bleat, my little goat, I pray, And take the table quite away,”

and then it will vanish again from yourthy sight.” ThenHereupon the wise woman leftdeparted. But Two-EyesTwo-eyes thought, “I must try it at onceinstantly make a trial, and see if what she said is true, for I am far too hungry,” and she said,

“Bleat, my little goat, bleat, Cover the table with something to eat,”

and as soon as she hadscarcely had she spoken the words, than a little table, covered with a white cloth, was standing there, and on it was a plate with a knife and fork, and a silver spoon; and the most delicious food was there also, warm and smoking as if it had just come out of the kitchen. Then Two-EyesTwo-eyes said the shortest prayer she knew, “Lord God, be with us always, Amen,” and helped herself to some food, and enjoyed it. And when she was satisfied, she said, as the wise woman had taught her,

“Bleat, bleat, my little goat, I pray, And take the table quite away,”

and immediately the little table and everything on it was gone again. “That is a delightful way to get a mealof keeping house!” thought Two-EyesTwo-eyes, and was quite glad and happy.

Illustration

In the evening, when she went home with her goat, she found a small earthenware dish with some food, which her sisters had set ready for her, but she did not touch it. Next day she again went out with her goat, and left the few scraps ofbits of broken bread which had been handed to her, lying untouched. The first and second time that she did this, her sisters did not noticeremark it at all, but as it happened every time, they did observe it, and said, “There is something wrong about Two-EyesTwo-eyes, she always leaves her food untasted, and she used to eat up everything that was given her; she must have discovered other ways of getting food.” To find outIn order that they might learn the truth, they decidedresolved to send One-EyeOne-eye with Two-EyesTwo-eyes when she went to drive her goat to the pasture, to watchobserve what Two-EyesTwo-eyes did when she was there, and whether any one brought her anything to eat and drink. So when Two-EyesTwo-eyes set out the next time, One-EyeOne-eye went to her and said, “I will go with you to the pasture, and see that the goat is well taken care of, and driven where there is food.” But Two-EyesTwo-eyes knew what was in One-Eye’sOne-eye’s mind, and drove the goat into high grass and said, “Come, One-EyeOne-eye, we will sit down, and I will sing something to you.” One-EyeOne-eye sat down and was tired from a walk she was not used towith the unaccustomed walk and the heat of the sun, and Two-Eyes kept singingTwo-eyes sang constantly,

“One-Eye, are you awakeOne eye, wakest thou? One-Eye, are you asleepOne eye, sleepest thou?”

until One-EyeOne-eye shut her one eye, and fell asleep, and as soon as Two-EyesTwo-eyes saw that One-EyeOne-eye was fast asleep, and could seediscover nothing, she said,

“Bleat, my little goat, bleat, Cover the table with something to eat,”

and seated herself at her table, and ate and drank until she was satisfied, and then she again cried,

“Bleat, bleat, my little goat, I pray, And take the table quite away,”

and in an instant all was gone. Two-EyesTwo-eyes now awakened One-EyeOne-eye, and said, “One-EyeOne-eye, you camewant to look aftertake care of the goat, but you wentand go to sleep insteadwhile you are doing it, and in the meantime the goat might run all over the world. Come, let us go home again.” So they went home, and again Two-EyesTwo-eyes let her little dish stand untouched, and One-EyeOne-eye could not tell her mother why she would not eat it, and to excuse herself said, “I fell asleep when I was out.”

Next day the mother said to Three-EyesThree-eyes, “This time you shallthou shalt go and see whether Two-Eyesobserve if Two-eyes eats anything when she is out, and whether anyone bringsif any one fetches her food and drink, for she must eat and drink in secret.” So Three-EyesThree-eyes went to Two-EyesTwo-eyes, and said, “I will go with you and see if the goat is taken proper care of, and driven where there is food.” But Two-EyesTwo-eyes knew what was in Three-EyesThree-eyes’ mind, and drove the goat into high grass and said, “We will sit down, and I will sing something to you, Three-EyesThree-eyes.” Three-EyesThree-eyes sat down and was tired with the walk and with the heat of the sun, and Two-EyesTwo-eyes began the same song as before, and sang,

“Three-EyesThree eyes, are you awakewaking?”

but then, instead of singing,

“Three-EyesThree eyes, are you asleepsleeping?”

as she shouldought to have done, she thoughtlessly sang,

“Two-EyesTwo eyes, are you asleepsleeping?”

and sang all the time,

“Three-EyesThree eyes, are you awakewaking? Two-EyesTwo eyes, are you asleepsleeping?”

Then two of Three-Eyes’the eyes closedwhich Three-eyes had, shut and fell asleep, but the third, as it had not been named in the song, did not sleep. Three-Eyes did closeIt is true that Three-eyes shut it, but only  in her cunning, to pretend it was asleep too. It kept peeping open, but it blinked, and could see everything perfectlyvery well. And when Two-EyesTwo-eyes thought that Three-EyesThree-eyes was fast asleep, she used her little charm,

“Bleat, my little goat, bleat, Cover the table with something to eat,”

and ate and drank as much as her heart desired, and then ordered the table to go away again,

“Bleat, bleat, my little goat, I pray, And take the table quite away,”

and Three-EyesThree-eyes had seen everything. Then Two-EyesTwo-eyes came to her, wokewaked her and said, “Have you been asleep, Three-Eyes? A fine goat-keeper you areThree-eyes? You are a good care-taker! Come, we will go home.” And when they got home, Two-EyesTwo-eyes again did not eat, and Three-EyesThree-eyes said to the mother, “Now, I know why that stuck-uphigh-minded thing there does not eat. When she is out, she says to the goat,

“Bleat, my little goat, bleat, Cover the table with something to eat,”

and then a little table appears before her covered with the best of food, much better than any we have here, and when she has eaten all she wants, she says,

“Bleat, bleat, my little goat, I pray, And take the table quite away,”

and all disappears. I watched everything closely. She put two of my eyes to sleep by singingusing a spellcertain form of words, but luckily the one in my forehead kept awake.” Then the envious mother cried, “Do youDost thou want to eatfare better than we do? I’ll soon put a stop to thatThe desire shall pass away,” and she fetched a butcher’s knife , and killedthrust it into the heart ofExplanation: The killing remains, but the precise stabbing of the animal’s heart is omitted for younger readers. the goat , which fell down dead.

When Two-EyesTwo-eyes saw that, she went out in distressfull of trouble, seated herself on the ridge of grass at the edge of the field, and wept bitter tears. Suddenly the wise woman once more stood by her side, and said, “Two-EyesTwo-eyes, why are you cryingart thou weeping?” “Don’tHave I havenot reason to cryweep?” she answered. “The goat which covered the table for me every day when I spoke your charm, has been killed by my mother, and now I shall again have to go hungrybear hunger and do withoutwant.” The wise woman said, “Two-EyesTwo-eyes, I will give youthee a piece of good advice; ask yourthy sisters to give youthee the goat’s insidesentrails of the slaughtered goatExplanation: The story requires the girl to bury part of the goat. A brief description replaces the unfamiliar anatomical word; all later mentions preserve the same remains., and bury them in the ground in front of the house, and your luckthy fortune will changebe made.” Then she vanished, and Two-EyesTwo-eyes went home and said to her sisters, “Dear sisters, do give me some part of my goat; I don’t wish for what is good, but give me its insidesthe entrails.” Then they laughed and said, “If that’s all you want, you can have it.” So Two-EyesTwo-eyes took those remainsthe entrails and buried them quietly in the evening, in front of the house-door, as the wise woman had advisedcounselled her to do.

Next morning, when they all awoke, and went to the house-door, there stood a strangely magnificent tree with leaves of silver, and fruit of gold hanging among them, so that in all the wide world there was nothing more beautiful or precious. They did not know how the tree could have come there during the night, but Two-EyesTwo-eyes saw that it had grown up fromout of the goat’s remainsentrails of the goat, for it was standing on the exact spot where she had buried them. Then the mother said to One-EyeOne-eye, “Climb up, my child, and gather some of the fruit of the tree for us.” One-EyeOne-eye climbed up, but when she was about to get hold of one of the golden apples, the branch escaped from her hands, and that happened each time, so that she could not pluck a single apple, no matterlet her do what she didmight. Then  said the mother saidmother, “Three-EyesThree-eyes, do you climb up; you with your three eyes can look about you better than One-EyeOne-eye.” One-EyeOne-eye slipped down, and Three-EyesThree-eyes climbed up. Three-EyesThree-eyes was nonot more skilful: no matter how hard, and might search as she tried,liked, but the golden apples always escaped her. At length the mother grew impatient, and climbed up herself, but could get hold of the fruit no better than One-EyeOne-eye and Three-EyesThree-eyes, for she always clutched empty air. Then Two-Eyes saidsaid Two-eyes, “I will just go up, perhaps I may succeed better.” The sisters cried, “You indeed, with your two eyes, what can you do?” But Two-EyesTwo-eyes climbed up, and the golden apples did not get out of her way, but came into her hand of their own accord, so that she could pluck them one after the other, and brought a whole apronful down with her. The mother took them away from her, and instead of treating poor Two-EyesTwo-eyes any better for this, she and One-EyeOne-eye and Three-EyesThree-eyes were only envious, because Two-EyesTwo-eyes alone had been able to get the fruit, and they treated her still more cruelly.

Illustration

One dayIt so befell that once when they were all standing together by the tree, a young knight came up. “Quick, Two-EyesTwo-eyes,” cried the two sisters, “creep under this, and don’t disgrace us!” and as quickly as they couldwith all speed they turned an empty barrel which was standing close by the tree over poor Two-EyesTwo-eyes, and they pushed the golden apples which she had been gathering, under it too. AsWhen the knight came nearer, they saw he was a handsome lord, who stopped and admired the magnificent gold and silver tree, and said to the two sisters, “Who ownsTo whom does this fine tree? Anyone belong? Any one who gives me awould bestow one branch of it may ask for whatever they wanton me might in return  for it ask whatsoever he desired.” Then One-EyeOne-eye and Three-EyesThree-eyes replied that the tree belonged to them, and that they would give him a branch. They both took great trouble, but they were not able to do it, for the branches and fruit both moved away from them every time. Then  said the knight saidknight, “It is very strange that the tree should belong to you, and that you should still not be able to break a piece off.” They again insistedasserted that the tree was their property. Whilst they were saying so, Two-EyesTwo-eyes rolled out a couple of golden apples from under the barrel to the feet of the knight, for she was annoyedvexed with One-EyeOne-eye and Three-EyesThree-eyes, for not speaking the truth. When the knight saw the apples he was astonished, and asked where they came from. One-EyeOne-eye and Three-EyesThree-eyes answered that they had another sister, who was not allowed to show herself, for she had only two eyes like any common person. The knight, however, wanteddesired to see her, and cried, “Two-EyesTwo-eyes, come outforth.” Then Two-EyesTwo-eyes, quite comforted, came from beneath the barrel, and the knight was surprised at her great beauty, and said, “You, Two-Eyes, canThou, Two-eyes, canst certainly break off a branch from the tree for me.” “Yes,” replied Two-EyesTwo-eyes, “that I certainly shall be able to do, for the tree belongs to me.” And she climbed up, and with the greatest ease broke off a branch with beautiful silver leaves and golden fruit, and gave it to the knight. Then  said the knight saidknight, “Two-EyesTwo-eyes, what shall I give youthee for it?” “Alas!” answered Two-EyesTwo-eyes, “I suffer from hunger and thirst, sadnessgrief and povertywant, from early morning till late night; if you would take me with you, and freedeliver me from all thisthese things, I should be happy.” So the knight lifted Two-EyesTwo-eyes on to his horse, and took her home with him to his father’s castle, and there he gave her beautiful clothes, and foodmeatExplanation: Here ‘meat’ has the older, general meaning of food. and drink to her heart’s content, and as he loved her so much he married her, and the wedding was celebratedsolemnized with great rejoicing. When Two-EyesTwo-eyes was thus carried away by the handsome knight, her two sisters bitterly resentedgrudged her good fortune  in downright earnest. “The wonderful tree, however, still remains with us,” thought they, “and even if we can gather no fruit from it, still every one will stand still and look at it, and come to us and admire it. Who knows what good things may be in store for us?” But next morning, the tree had vanished, and all their hopes were at an end. And when Two-EyesTwo-eyes looked out of the window of her own little room, to her great delight it was standing in front of it, and so it had followed her.

Illustration

Two-EyesTwo-eyes lived a long time in happiness. Once two poor women came to her in her castle, and begged for helpalms. She looked in their faces, and recognized her sisters, One-EyeOne-eye, and Three-EyesThree-eyes, who had fallen into such poverty that they had to wander about and beg for foodtheir bread from door to door. Two-EyesTwo-eyes, however, made them welcome, and was kind to them, and took care of them, so that they both with all their hearts regrettedrepented the cruel thingsevil that they had done to their sister when they were youngin their youth.

Quiz

Question 1 / 5

What shape are a goat’s pupils?