The Spirit in the Bottle
In this German story collected by the Brothers Grimm, a student has to stop studying because his father’s money has run out. While helping him cut wood, he hears a mysterious voice beneath an old oak.
Content warning: A spirit threatens to kill the young man who sets him free.
Piano Trio in B-flat major, Op. 11
Once upon a time there wasThere was once a poor woodcutter who toiled from early morning till late night. When at last he had savedlaid by some money he said to his boy, “You are my only child, I will spend the money which I have earned with the sweat of my brow on your education; if you learn some honest trade you can support me in my old age, when my arms and legslimbs have grown stiff and I haveam obliged to stay at home.” Then the boy went to a collegeHigh SchoolExplanation: ‘High School’ here means a place of higher study, not the modern school for teenagers. The boy later returns to study and becomes a doctor. and studied hard,learned diligently so that his teachersmasters praised him, and he remained there a long time. When he had completedworked through two classes, but hadwas still not yet finished his studiesperfect in everything, the little money hispittance which the father had earned was all spent, and the boy hadwas obliged to return home to him. “Ah,” said the father, sorrowfully, “I can give you no more, and in these hard times I cannot earn a pennyfarthing more than we needwill suffice for our daily foodbread.” “Dear father,” answered the son, “don’t trouble yourself about it, if it is God’s will, it will turn out for the best.to my advantage I shall soon get usedaccustom myself to it.” When the father wanted to go into the forest to earn money by helping to pile and stack wood and also chop it, the son said, “I will go with you and help you.” “NoNay, my son,” said the father, “that would be hard for you; you are not usedaccustomed to hard physicalrough work, and will not be able to manage it. Besides,bear it, besides I have only one axe and no money left wherewith to buy another.” “Just go to the neighbour,” answered the son, “he will lend you his axe until I have earned one for myself.” The father then borrowed an axe fromof the neighbour, and next morning at break of day they went out into the forest together. The son helped his father and worked cheerfullywas quite merry and energeticallybrisk about it. But when the sun was right over their heads, the father said, “We will rest, and have our midday meal. Thendinner, and then we can workshall work as well again.” The son took his bread in his hands, and said, “Just you rest, father, I am not tired; I will walk up and down a little in the forest, and look for birds’ nests.” “Oh, you fool,” said the father, “why should you want to run about there? Afterwards you will be tired, and no longer able to raise your arm; stay here, and sit down beside me.” The son, however, went into the forest, ate his bread, was very merry and peered in among the green branches to see if he could discover a bird’s nest anywhere. He kept searchingSo he went up and down to see if he could find a bird’s nest until at last he came to a great dangerous-looking oak, which was certainlycertainly was already many hundreds ofhundred years old. Its trunk was so wide that even, and whichExplanation: The comparison measures the width around the tree, not its height. The original image of five men is retained. five men with their arms stretched outmen could not have reached around itspanned. He stood still and looked at it, and thought, “Many a bird must have built its nest in that.” Then all at once it seemed to him that he heard a voice. He listened and heard someonebecame aware that someone was crying in a very muffledsmothered voice, “Let me out, let me out!” He looked around, but could discover nothing; butnevertheless, he thoughtfancied that the voice came out of the ground. Then he cried, “Where are youart thou?” The voice answered, “I am down here amongst the roots of the oak-tree. Let me out! Let me out!” The student The scholar began to loosen the earth under the tree, and search among the roots, until at last he found a glass bottle in a little hollow. He lifted it up and held it up toagainst the light, and then saw a creature shaped like a frog, springing up and down in it. “Let me out! Let me out!” it cried againanew, and the student suspecting nothingscholar thinking no evil, drew the cork out of the bottle. Immediately a spirit rose out ofascended from it, and began to grow, and grew so fast that in a very few moments he stood before the studentscholar, a terrible fellow halfas big as tall ashalf the tree beside himby which he was standing. “Do you knowKnowest thou,” he cried in an awful voice, “what your reward isthy wages are for lettinghaving let me out?” “No,” replied the studentscholar fearlessly, “how should I know that?” “Then I will tell youthee,” cried the spirit; “I must strangle youthee for it.” “You shouldThou shouldst have told me that sooner,” said the studentscholar, “for I should then have left youthee shut up, but you won’t get rid of me so easily. I have a say in this toomy head shall stand fast for all thou canst do; more persons than one must be consulted about that.” “A say in this, a say in thatMore persons here, more persons there,” said the spirit. “You shallThou shalt have the reward you havewages thou hast earned. Do youDost thou think that I was shut up there for such a long time as a favour?. No, it was a punishment for me. I am the mighty Mercurius. WhoeverWhoso releases me, I musthim must I strangle.” “Easy thereSoftly,” answered the studentscholar, “not so fast. I must first know that youthou really werewert shut up in that little bottle, and that you arethou art the sameright spirit. If, indeed, you canthou canst get in again, I will believe and then you maythou mayst do as you willthou wilt with me.” The spirit said haughtily, “Thatthat is a very easy tricktrifling feat,” drew himself together, and made himself as small and slender as he had been at first, so that he crept through the same opening, and backright through the neck of the bottle. As soon as he in again. Scarcely was inside,he within than the studentscholar thrust the cork he had drawn back into the bottle, and threw it among the roots of the oak into its old place, and the spirit had been trickedwas betrayed.
And now the studentscholar was about to return to his father, but the spirit cried pitifullyvery piteously, “Ah, do let me out! ah, do let me out!” “No,” answered the studentscholar, “not a second time! He who has once tried to take my life shall not be set free by me, now that I have caught him again.” “If you willthou wilt set me free,” said the spirit, “I will give youthee so much that you willthou wilt have plenty all the days of yourthy life.” “No,” answered the boy, “you wouldthou wouldst cheat me as you didthou didst the first time.” “You are throwingThou art playing away yourwith thy own good luck,” said the spirit; “I will do youthee no harm but will reward youthee richly.” The studentscholar thought, “I will riskventure it, perhaps he will keep his word, and anyhow he shall not get the better of me.” Then he took out the cork, and the spirit rose up from the bottle as he had done before, stretched himself out and became as big as a giant. “Now you shallthou shalt have yourthy reward,” said he, and handed the studentscholar a small healing padlittle bag just like a plasterExplanation: Hunt compares the magical object to a medical plaster: a dressing laid over a wound. One end heals and the other turns iron or steel into silver., and said, “If you laythou spreadest one end of this over a wound it will heal, and if you rubthou rubbest steel or iron with the other end it will be changed into silver.” “I must just try that,” said the studentscholar, and went to a tree, tore off the bark with his axe, and rubbed it with one end of the pad. The damaged barkplaster. It immediately closed up andtogether and was healed. “Now, it is all right,” he said to the spirit, “and we can part.” The spirit thanked him for his release, and the boy thanked the spirit for his present, and went back to his father.
“Where have youhast thou been racing about?” said the father; “why have youhast thou forgotten yourthy work? I said at once that you wouldthou wouldst never get on with anything.” “Don’t worryBe easy, father, I will make it up.” “Make it up indeed,” said the father angrily, “that’s easy enough to saythere’s no art in that.” “WatchTake care, father. I’ll, I will soon chophew that tree in twothere, so that it will split.” Then he took his padplaster, rubbed the axe with it, and dealt a mighty blow, but becauseas the iron had changed into silver, the blade bentedge turned; “HelloHollo, father, just look what a bad axe you’ve given me, it has become quite crooked.” The father was shocked and said, “Ah, what have youhast thou done? now I shall have to pay for that, and dohave not have the moneythe wherewithal, and that is all the good your work has done meI have got by thy work.” “Don’t get angry,” said the son, “I will soon pay for the axe.” “Oh, youthou blockhead,” cried the father, “what will youwherewith wilt thou pay for it with? You have? Thou hast nothing but what I give you. Your head is full ofthee. These are students’ tricks that are sticking in thy head, but you havethou hast no idea of wood-cutting.” After a while the studentscholar said, “Father, I can really work no more, we had better take a holiday.” “Eh, what!” answered he, “Do youDost thou think I will sit here doing nothingwith my hands lying in my lap like youthee? I must go on working, but you may gothou mayst take thyself off home.” “Father, this is my first timeI am here in this wood for the first time, I don’t know my way alone. Do go with me.” As his anger had now cooledabated, the father at last let himself be persuaded and went home with him. Then he said to the son, “Go and sell yourthy damaged axe, and see what you canthou canst get for it, and I must earn the difference, in order to pay the neighbour.” The son took the axe, and carried it into town to a goldsmith, who tested it, laid it in the scales, and said, “It is worth four hundred silver coinsthalersExplanation: Thalers were large silver coins. Later the story also names groschen, smaller coins. The modern reading keeps both amounts and the doubled payment, without inventing a present-day exchange rate., I don’t have thathave not so much withas that by me.” The son said, “Give me what you havethou hast, I will lend you the rest.” The goldsmith gave him three hundred silver coinsthalers, and still owed himremained a hundred in his debt. The son thenthereupon went home and said, “Father, I have got the money, go and ask the neighbour what he wants for the axe.” “I know that already,” answered the old man, “one silver coin andthaler, six smaller coinsgroschen.” “Then give him two silver coins andthalers, twelve smaller coinsgroschen, that is double and enough; see, I have money in plenty,” and he gave the father a hundred silver coinsthalers, and said, “You shall never go without anything you needknow want, live as comfortably as you like.” “Good heavens!” said the father, “how have youhast thou come by these riches?” The studentscholar then told how itall had all happenedcome to pass, and how he, trusting in his luck, had done so wellmade such a good hit. But with the money that was left, he went back to collegethe High School and went on learning more, and as he could heal all wounds with his padplaster, he became the most famous doctor in the whole world.